Thursday, April 17, 2014

The Book Thief.

I read The Book Thief several years ago and really enjoyed it. Well, if "enjoyed" is the correct word to use when you're talking about a haunting story set in Nazi Germany. It's a book that sticks with you...between the lyrical writing style and the fact that the narrator is Death, it's a pretty memorable book. I was excited to hear that there was a film adaptation coming, and I reread the book back in December in anticipation of the film. But then it turned out that the movie didn't come to our theater, so I added it to my Netflix list, and I finally got to see it this week.


It was a really beautiful film. I was worried from the trailer that the tone of it might be a little too light, considering how dark the book can be. But they actually did a really good job of balancing humor and lighter moments with the more dramatic ones. This is a good book-to-film adaptation...I noticed a few things that were left out or changed, but overall it stuck pretty closely to the book and all of the important things are still there.

The cinematography is really gorgeous, and the costumes and sets were great. (The book burning scene was visually stunning, though as a book lover, it made me cringe. I also loved all of the snowy scenes.) The outside of the house and the street weren't exactly how I had imagined them, but the inside of the house was. The music was also amazing.


The casting was one of the best parts of the movie...it was seriously perfect. Sophie Nelisse, the girl who played the main character Liesel, was amazing. Not only was she adorable (those curls!), but she's also a really good actress. I loved the transformation from the silent girl at the beginning to the confident girl she became later on, telling stories in the bomb shelter during air raids. (And have I mentioned how adorable she was??) And they really couldn't have found anyone better than Geoffrey Rush to play her foster father, Hans. Oh my goodness, he was perfect and exactly what I was imagining when I read the book. I loved it when he played the accordion. I was also really impressed with Emily Watson as Rosa, the foster mother. They toned back Rosa's nastiness big time for the film, and I'm glad because while she's still grumpy, she's so much more likable. :)


I've read quite a few WWII stories, especially ones involving the Holocaust. But this is the first story I've ever read that takes place from the viewpoint of ordinary German people living under Hitler. I think most of us tend to be really judgmental towards them and wonder how they could have let those terrible things happen. But The Book Thief does a good job of showing the fear that they lived under, worrying what awful things would happen to them if they dared speak out against the Fuhrer.

My favorite scene was probably the one where Liesel and Rudy were out in the woods shouting "I hate Hitler!" As children, they probably didn't understand the extent of Hitler's evil...they just know that he's done things that have taken away people they love and changed their lives. I also love basically any scene with Liesel and Hans together. Their relationship is so sweet. And for different reasons, I appreciated the scene when the Nazis are checking basements...it was really good and appropriately tense.


The one thing about the book that bugs me is the profanity. Bad language is one of my pet peeves, and the book unfortunately includes a lot of it. It's also just a bit too crass at times. I'm glad the movie steered away from that...in that way, it actually improved on the book (in my opinion :).

Like I said, The Book Thief is such a beautiful movie, and I really recommend it. It's not a feel-good film by any means, so don't watch it if you're in the mood for something cheerful. (The end will make you cry. If you've read the book, you know what I mean. It's even more heartbreaking seeing it happen, though it's handled in a really graceful way.) But it's definitely worth watching.

Have you read The Book Thief or seen the film? What did you think?

10 comments:

  1. The Book Thief is one of my very favorite books. I thought the movie was wonderful...like you said, the casting was just perfect. Especially Max and Papa.

    I really enjoyed hearing what you thought about the movie!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Papa was amazing. :) Actually, the only casting I was a little iffy about was Max. He looked like I imagined, but for some reason I had a hard time clicking with his character in the film as much as I did in the book. I don't know why!

      I'm glad to hear that you liked the movie, too. :)

      Delete
  2. Bummer. I'm sorry to read the book has a lot of profanity. My aunt wanted to read the book and I just received the book from her as a gift (yep, we just had our family Christmas after several delays ;D); we actually gave it to each other. That being said, I'll give the book a shot as I've heard great things about it plus will likely see the film at some point (once I'm in the mood to see something "darker") - glad to know it keeps the crassness to a minimum.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You should still definitely read the book! It's unlike anything I've ever read. Profanity is just one of those things that really bugs me. But if I'm remembering correctly, some of it is in German. So even though it's translated at times and you know what it means, it's slightly less jarring than reading it in English. If that makes sense... :) Anyway, don't let the language turn you away from reading the book, because it's still worth reading. Just make sure you read the book before you watch the film. It will give you a bit more backstory and I feel like you would lose some of the emotional impact if you watched the movie first. :) Just my opinion, anyway.

      Delete
  3. I enjoyed reading the book so much and I'm excited that you recommend the movie! I can't wait to see it!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you'll like the movie when you see it! :)

      Delete
  4. I plan on buying the book and going through it with whiteout. It is sooooo good. So well-written. Partially I think because the author's parents went through that in their childhood.
    The book is so much better than the movie. The movie is too sanitized about the war (the Dachau march of the Jews part) and not as developed as the book (that is just not possibly because of the medium of film to medium of book differences), but it is still sooooo sweet. My sisters and I thought Rudy was sooo adorable. I want a little blond child boy for my first kid I think. The kids were so cute together.
    I don't think the story can be fully appreciated without reading the book first.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The movie is a little sanitized. I appreciate that when it comes to the profanity, but I agree about the march of the Jews. The kids were really cute together. And I agree, I definitely recommend that people read the book first.

      Delete
  5. I'm very excited to see this! Hopefully soon... :) Even before reading any reviews and hearing that it was a good adaptation, I was in love with the look of the cast (especially Rudy - what a cute kid!).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope you like it when you see it! The cast really is one of the best parts. :)

      Delete

Please feel free to leave a comment, I love to read them! :) I reply to each one, so be sure to check back, especially if you asked a question.